Comments on: Protective Trail Shoe Review Roundup 2016: Montrail Trans Alps, La Sportiva Akasha, Saucony Xodus ISO, Altra Lone Peak 3.0, Pearl Izumi Trail N3, The North Face Ultra Endurance https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html Running Shoes, Gear Reviews, and Posts on the Science of the Sport Mon, 26 Dec 2016 15:32:52 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.7.12 By: Berto https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130543466 Mon, 26 Dec 2016 15:32:52 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130543466 In reply to David Henry.

Thanks!

Never thought on the Nike Kieger 3! If you say it is narrow on heel and midfoot, but wide on toebox it could be perfect for me. Thanks again!

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130538247 Mon, 19 Dec 2016 19:52:22 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130538247 In reply to Berto.

TOPO is good in this regard, but I do actually prefer Nike’s trail shoe fit (Kiger 3 and Wildhorse 3) probably better than TOPO even. Skechers is getting better too in this regard although I wouldn’t say their heel is narrow but medium. Altra will also have a new shoe called the King MT that will be on their Racing last and it should fit narrow from heel through midfoot but with wider forefoot. I’ll be covering many of these as they get released. -David

]]>
By: feelthhis https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130538229 Mon, 19 Dec 2016 19:28:44 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130538229 In reply to Berto.

Some months ago I made exactly this question and here are some other options:

https://runblogger.com/2016/06/topo-mt-2-and-hydroventure-large-refinements-in-topos-trail-line.html#comment-1130437926

(Nike Kieger 3, New Balance NL-1 last, inov-8 Standard Fit, Skecher newer models)

]]>
By: Berto https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130537019 Sun, 18 Dec 2016 23:22:11 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130537019 So, after reading this article and the posts, it seems that the best “fit” for “narrow heel and midfoot, and wide toebox” could be a TOPO (Runventure or MT), isn’t it?

Anyother option?

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130536076 Sun, 18 Dec 2016 03:23:13 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130536076 In reply to Bruce.

Yes the FKT laces at a lower. I’d say the Caldorado seemed a bit larger than the TA and it is a different last too. Personally I wouldn’t size down but can’t say for sure.

David

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130535139 Fri, 16 Dec 2016 02:44:03 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130535139 In reply to David Henry.

sorry, david, just to be sure i’m clear, you’re saying fkt laces at a lower volume, right?
i briefly tried on caldorado at a store and was able to size down comfortably. do you think that would be the case also with the two trans alps?

thanks again,
bruce

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130535075 Fri, 16 Dec 2016 00:24:45 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130535075 In reply to Bruce.

Trans Alps is a bit more snug than Caldorado but not drastically so and all are what I’d consider medium fitting shoes. Trans Alps FKT fits same as regular TA but maybe a bit more stretch to fabric since it lacks the rand of the regular Trans Alps. Biggest difference between those two is that the reg TA has lace loops and TA FKT doesn’t so it laces at an effective lower volume (even though last volume is the same).

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130534965 Thu, 15 Dec 2016 19:14:15 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130534965 thanks, david. do you find any difference in fit, snugness, or sizing among the two trans alps and the caldorado?

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130534934 Thu, 15 Dec 2016 17:50:13 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130534934 In reply to Bruce.

Hi Bruce,

I think the Trans Alps would be my pick if I was going to double as a hiking shoe. The FKT is lighter in both upper and midsole (and softer). I like both of them for different reasons and you can’t go too wrong with either (and they are cheap right now due the the rebranding they are undergoing!). I think the Trans Alps runs smoother than the Caldorado and the Trans Alps FKT probably is a good compromise between the Trans Alps and Caldorado (weighs the same or maybe a bit less than Caldorado even).

I’ve tried the Rogue FKT on but not run in it. I was thinking at the cheap price on RW, I might give it a whirl. It isn’t going to be super protective but light and nimble.

As far as the FKT vs ST the ride isn’t really different just the upper. I prefer the FKT upper (lower volume and lower heel collar height) but the ride is equally decent on both.

Take care. -David

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130534865 Thu, 15 Dec 2016 15:18:39 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130534865 hi david–welcome back! i’m trying to choose between caldorado, trans alps, and trans alps fkt. would caldorado still be a better choice for not too technical terrain? i’m hoping to get something that could also work well doubling as a hiking shoe. any disdavantages of fkt vs. original trans alps? might it run as smoothly as caldorado?

have you tried rogue fkt?

and on the lighter side, is there much dif. in the ride of fluidflex fkt vs. st?

thanks,
bruce

]]>
By: feelthhis https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130534600 Wed, 14 Dec 2016 23:17:25 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130534600 In reply to David Henry.

Seems like a very good shoe to pound the pavement with easy/long runs!

]]>
By: feelthhis https://runblogger.com/2016/12/protective-trail-shoe-review-roundup-2016-montrail-trans-alps-la-sportiva-akasha-saucony-xodus-iso-altra-lone-peak-3-0-pearl-izumi-trail-n3-the-north-face-ultra-endurance.html#comment-1130534596 Wed, 14 Dec 2016 23:11:52 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=2159485#comment-1130534596 In reply to David Henry.

It helps a lot. Thanks!

Looking forward for King MT and Escalante. And Topo Terraventure! And Torin 2.5, of course. Lot of options (narrow heel wide forefoot) now!

]]>