Comments on: Trail Shoe Review Roundup: Montrail Fluid Flex ST, Scarpa TRU, Altra Superior 2.0, North Face Ultra MT, Brooks Cascadia 10 https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html Running Shoes, Gear Reviews, and Posts on the Science of the Sport Mon, 27 Jun 2016 00:06:43 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.7.11 By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130439664 Mon, 27 Jun 2016 00:06:43 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130439664 In reply to Marcus.

Thanks for the update Marcus and good to here the toebox issues were fixed in the new Superior 2.0. That model has tons of potential with a little refinement. It is still my favorite Altra to date. -David

]]>
By: Marcus https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130435490 Fri, 17 Jun 2016 07:35:04 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130435490 Hi David, i waited for the Dynafit vertikal pro but they never came to stores here with my big size so I bought the Altra superior 2.0. I have revaluated the tight toe box as my problems with the toes has improved with a bigger toe box though IT tok some time to get used to it.. Overall I really like the concept of Altra with wider toebox and zero drop, it feels more natural and i can run a lot longer without getting burnt out in my legs. I hope they improve the heel cap to the next version to be deeper or higher, I run without the rock plate doesnt feel I need It!

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130429330 Wed, 01 Jun 2016 21:56:28 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130429330 In reply to Bruce.

Hi Bruce. No worries. I was out traveling till yesterday so didn’t see the comment. I have a pair of Sense Pro 2, but haven’t run in them yet. Will probably get out in them later in the week, but just from trying them on I’d say they probably are not that different in feel…maybe a little softer/more cushioned but not by much. -David

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130426429 Fri, 27 May 2016 04:54:06 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130426429 In reply to David Henry.

thanks again. sorry, one more–have you tried sense pro 2 yet? i’ve seen a couple people saying that while it’s more cushioned than the original, it’s also (even) stiffer.

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130426290 Thu, 26 May 2016 21:21:48 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130426290 In reply to Bruce.

Yeah they seemed true to size to me…at least true to my NB size…I do fine NB runs just a bit shorter (like 1/4 size) than many other brands.

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130425952 Wed, 25 May 2016 23:47:47 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130425952 did v4 and v3 seem true to size to you? as i mentioned, i found v1 true to size but v2 a bit short.

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130425898 Wed, 25 May 2016 20:47:41 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130425898 In reply to Bruce.

I actually tried the 1690 back when it came out and I just don’t have good luck with NB’s PL last which the 1690 was on. I agree that overall design was solid, which is why it caught my attention, but I could jive with the fit.

I’ve tried on the 1400v4 but haven’t run in them. Fit is right on with previous models and it did seem like there was just a bit more shoe, but I would guess it wouldn’t run substantially different. I’ll probably try it down the road when I can find it cheaper sometime.

RE: Shoefitr, I don’t know what happened to it…I used to use it on Running Warehouse, but since they stopped having it, I haven’t come across it elsewhere.

David

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130425465 Tue, 24 May 2016 22:57:41 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130425465 In reply to David Henry.

thanks for laying it all out for me, david.

one flash-in-the-pan model you might be interested in if you can find it–because, well, they’re shoes–is the NB MT1690. from a couple of years ago, lasted maybe one year (seemingly no effort to make people aware of it). the cushioning is definitely not minimal (weight around 9 oz.), though the drop is 4 mm and feels a bit lower than that. great fit/last (with great lacing)–quite snug in the heel and midfoot, moderate room in forefoot. very fast-and-free feeling to me; pretty flexible, but nothing like original fluidflex. (can’t vouch for it on technical, no experience, unusual outsole.) just a thought…

have you tried NB 1400v4? supposedly increased stack height, for better or worse. if you have, how does it compare to v3? did midsole change at all from v1 to v2 and v3? (i only had v1.) v1 fit me very well in my typical size. v2 seemed to run short. what about v3 and v4?

and fwiw, does shoefitr exist anywhere anymore?

much thanks,
bruce

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130423415 Wed, 18 May 2016 17:39:45 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130423415 In reply to Bruce.

Yes, I’ve run in the Summit and just got a pair of the pace pretty cheap (haven’t run in them yet though). The Summits are interesting…on one hand I like the racing flat feel to them and they do remind me of a more refined MT101, but I also feel they are really harsh riding (very firm foam on them, that doesn’t give the same rebound that firm adidas foam does, like the XT5), Besides the upper being better on the Summit, I think the XT5 and XT Boost are superior shoes to the summit. -David

]]>
By: David Henry https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130423414 Wed, 18 May 2016 17:37:12 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130423414 In reply to Bruce.

Hi Bruce, Yes the FF II and ST are discontinued. I don’t really feel the FKT was a huge improvement over the ST other than it fit my lower volume foot much better and I think the upper is more refined overall. -David

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130423395 Wed, 18 May 2016 16:53:46 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130423395 PS: any experience yet with the vazee summit? (also, did you ever run in the vazee pace?)

]]>
By: Bruce https://runblogger.com/2016/05/trail-shoe-review-roundup-montrail-fluid-flex-st-scarpa-tru-altra-superior-2-0-north-face-ultra-mt-brooks-cascadia-10.html#comment-1130421874 Sat, 14 May 2016 16:25:55 +0000 http://runblogger.com/?p=1664066#comment-1130421874 In reply to David Henry.

thanks, david. so you don’t see any real advantage to xt5 or mt101 over FF ST, aside perhaps from weight?
do you know if FF II and/or ST are being discontinued? i liked the first two versions of FF a lot more than you did, at least for easier trails. i know the review is coming, but did you find a big improvement in FKT over ST? (i really can’t look at FKT without hearing a certain phrase in my head.)

best,
bruce

]]>