My story is actually the reverse of the typical person seeking minimalist shoe advice. I have been running regularly for the past two years (started later in life), and began running in VFF from the beginning. I fully adjusted (calves/legs/feet), and my very flat-feet have actually developed arches. What used to be miserable when I tried it in the past has become pleasurable thanks to discovering minimal running. I have run a road marathon in Vibram Bikilas and a 50k trail race in Merrell Trailgloves.
As much as I love running in my VFFs and Trailgloves, I am really wanting to feel less soreness in my feet when I run very long distances, so I am seeking a shoe that I can run my next 50k race in (May 4) where I continue to run with the same gait and form that I do in the VFFs, but with some cushion so that my feet aren't as beat up after a 50k. In other words I don't want to undo any of my progress in being a minimalist runner.
I've had little luck with this on the internet because most of the advice is about transitioning to minimalist running, whereas I started with minimal running and have no context or experience with more.